Justia Badge
Lawyers Weekly
Martindale-Hubbell
AVVO.
Super Lawyers.
Super Lawyers
WBA Supporter
Massachusetts Academy of Trial Attorneys
The National Trial Lawyers
Top Ten Ranking
Top 40 Under 40
AVVO
Top 100
Best Lawyers 2020 Badge
Best Lawyers - Best Law Firms 2020

$350,000 Arbitration Award for Wrongful Death - Patient Dies After Cardiac Condition Untreated

The 58-year-old decedent had a family history of cardiac disease and a medical history that included high blood pressure, high cholesterol and smoking until the age of 50. He had been under the care and treatment of his primary care physician for several years prior to his death.

On December 15, 1997, the decedent telephoned his physician's office with complaints of throat and nasal congestion. The next day, the decedent went to see his physician, complaining that he was "having a hard time breathing." He also complained of chest congestion, shortness of breath on exertion and a dry cough.

A physician's assistant ordered a chest X-ray and EKG, both of which were essentially normal, but during an informal exercise stress test the decedent developed audible wheezes and labored breathing.

The assistant discussed the case with the defendant primary care physician, but the defendant did not examine the decedent. Based on that discussion, the defendant thought the decedent had a respiratory infection or asthma, although he recognized that a more serious respiratory or cardiac condition had not been ruled out.

The plaintiff alleged that the defendant deviated from the standard of care by failing to refer the decedent to the emergency department for further work up.

The plaintiff claimed that if the decedent had been referred to the emergency department, he would have been stabilized and worked up for serious cardiac and pulmonary conditions; he would have received treatment for his coronary artery disease; and, if the pulmonary embolus was present at the time, he would have been administered medication to break up the clot.

At arbitration, the defendant argued that given the negative findings on the chest X-ray and EKG, outpatient treatment was appropriate. The defendant presented expert testimony that the pulmonary embolus was not present at the time the decedent was seen in the office and did not occur until or around the time the decedent collapsed. He also presented expert testimony that immediate hospitalization would not have prevented death because there was not sufficient time for evaluation and treatment of the decedent's condition in the several hours before he died.

The plaintiff prevailed at arbitration.

Client Reviews
★★★★★
We wanted to thank you again so much for all you did for us and your support throughout this ordeal. You did a great job for us and we truly appreciate it. We wish you well always. Dot and Alex
★★★★★
We are extremely happy that we chose Kathy Jo Cook as our attorney. She brings experience, knowledge and compassion into the complicated legal process. Day or night, Attorney Cook always had time to talk to us and answer any questions we had throughout. We highly recommend her. Christopher & Mary Casella
★★★★★
KJC Law firm handled my case and I was very pleased with the results. The Team there always returned my calls or emails quickly. They are very direct and upfront on how they feel the case will go and the best ways of handling it. I would definitely call them again should I need their assistance and will recommend them to others highly. J G.
★★★★★
Law firm represented myself and another individual in a work related age discrimination case and was successful in obtaining a settlement in our favor. Couldn't be happier with the results and the representation. Mike K.
★★★★★
I have worked with Kathy Jo Cook for over a decade. She has represented me in both personal and professional matters and has given 150% every time. Kathy Jo is hardworking and always has my best interests in mind. She is professional and reliable and has been accessible as needed, even after business hours. Kathy has expertise in many areas of law and is incredibly fair and ethical in her client work. We secured favorable outcomes every time that have enabled me to enjoy more happiness, health and success in my life. Mindy